Shin splints, a common issue for runners, can cause your lower leg muscles, tendons, and bone tissue to become swollen and inflamed. This painful condition may result from improper running form, muscle weakness, overuse, and wearing worn-out shoes. In addition to strengthening, rest and stretching, one of the best ways to alleviate pain and prevent future flare-ups is to wear supportive, well-fitting running shoes.
To find the best running shoes for shin splints, we tested hundreds of pairs in The Verywell Testing Lab and at home, running on concrete, trails, treadmills, and more. Next, we spoke with experts, including podiatrists and orthopedic surgeons, about what key features to look for when shopping for a high-quality option. We then evaluated each pair for fit, comfort, cushioning, responsiveness, stability, and value to find the top options on the market.
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 5–12 (medium, wide), Men’s 6–15 (medium, wide) | Weight: Women’s 7.9 ounces, Men’s 9.2 ounces | Drop: 8 millimeters | Cushioning: Maximum | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.9/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners who want a supportive, well-cushioned shoe that works for outdoor or treadmill running, as well as for everyday wear.Â
Why We Love Them
Asics’ Novablast 4 Running Shoes are our top overall pick because they’re durable with supportive cushioning, which is key for those prone to shin splint flare-ups. During testing, we immediately noticed their comfy but firm midsole, which made our runs and walks feel easier and put some extra spring in our steps. The cushioning also protected our joints from impact during treadmill and outdoor runs on pavement.
Despite its maximum cushioning, this lightweight shoe delivers a supportive, secure fit without feeling heavy or restrictive. During long periods of wear, our feet didn’t feel hot or confined, thanks to its soft, breathable upper. We also love that this pair is versatile for all types of runs and everyday wear.
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon.
Potential FlawsÂ
- This shoe may feel narrow for some, so consider sizing up or selecting a wide-width size if you prefer more room in the toe box.
Meet Our Testers
Our tester has plantar fasciitis (inflammation of the thick band of tissue that connects the heel bone to the toes), flat feet, and a previous knee injury. She was pleased that this shoe’s supportive cushioning didn’t aggravate any of her conditions and helped prevent new issues and flare-ups.
-
Very responsive
-
Great shock absorption
-
Breathable
-
Shallow tread
-
Not ideal for speedwork
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 5–12 (medium, wide), Men’s 7–15 (medium, wide) | Weight: Women’s 8 ounces, Men’s 9.1 ounces | Drop: 8 millimeters | Cushioning: Plush and springy | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.9/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners and walkers who want supportive, comfy sneakers that absorb shock well.
Why We Love Them
If you’re new to running or getting started again after a break, Saucony’s Ride Running Shoe is a great option for a daily trainer. During testing (we tested the Saucony 17, which is the previous model), we found this shoe offered the perfect amount of cushioning, support, and propulsion. The shoes felt so breathable and comfortable that we didn’t want to take them off after our runs. The Saucony 18 adds padding to the tongue and is slightly lighter than the model we tested.
Runners will appreciate the full-length foam midsole, which provides a soft, smooth ride without feeling too squishy or bulky. The cushioning definitely helped propel us forward and made our outdoor runs feel easier. We also love how comfortable and supportive they are for walking, so much so that we regularly reach for these for our daily three-mile walks. We think they’re a solid option if you prefer a run/walk technique for your miles.
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon, Saucony, and Zappos.
Potential Flaws
- This shoe’s tread is a bit shallow, so it may be best for running on roads, tracks, or treadmills rather than uneven or wet surfaces.
- While this pair’s support and cushioning are perfect for daily training, they may be too heavy for speedwork.
Meet Our Testers
One of our testers, who has a history of plantar fasciitis, runs regularly and found that this shoe had better shock absorption than other running shoes she’s previously worn. Our other tester sometimes feels some post-run knee pain but didn’t experience any soreness during or after running in this pair.
Key Specs
Sizes: Men’s 7–15 (narrow, medium, wide, extra-wide), Women’s 5–13 (narrow, medium, wide, extra-wide) | Weight: Men’s 10.1 ounces, Women’s 9 ounces | Drop: 10 millimeters | Cushioning: Moderate | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.5/5
Who They’re For
Best for neutral runners who need a well-cushioned, supportive shoe that can withstand the pounding of running on pavement.
Why We Love Them
Brooks’ Ghost Road Running Shoe earned our top spot for road running thanks to its exceptional comfort, shock absorption, and performance. During testing, its soft but firm cushioning provided stellar support and shock absorption, keeping our feet, legs, and joints protected and pain-free. Plus, this shoe has earned the American Podiatric Medical Association’s (APMA) Seal of Acceptance, meaning a group of podiatrists has determined that its design supports good foot health.
This pair features a spacious toe box and comes in wide sizes, making it a good choice if you have bunions (a painful growth on the big toe joint), ankle instabilities, or are prone to blisters. We also love that its soft, stretchy upper is breathable, keeping our feet comfortable and preventing overheating when we run outside, even after a six-mile loop. We think these shoes are durable, everyday trainers that can easily handle repeated pounding on asphalt and concrete.
Also available in women’s sizes at Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods, and Brooks.
Potential Flaws
- While this shoe’s cushioning provides exceptional impact protection, it doesn’t feel as responsive as other options on our list.
Meet Our Testers
One of our testers is a distance runner who has been wearing Brooks running shoes for years. He found the Brooks Ghost extremely comfortable and durable—similar to previous models. Our other tester runs regularly and found its soft but firm cushioning perfect for running on pavement.Â
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 5–12 (medium, wide, extra-wide), Men’s 7–16 (medium, wide, extra-wide) | Weight: Women’s 8.6 ounces, Men’s 9.6 ounces | Drop: 6 millimeters | Cushioning: Plush and responsive | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 5/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners with flat feet who want a well-cushioned shoe with good impact protection and responsiveness.
Why We Love Them
Saucony’s Guide Sneaker offers exceptional impact protection on a variety of surfaces, making it a good pick for runners who have a history of shin splints. With extra-supportive cushioning in the midfoot, it’s also ideal if you have flat feet and need more arch support in your running shoes. During test runs on pavement and gravel, our feet and arches were well-supported, and we didn’t notice any pain in our knees or other joints. While we tested Saucony’s Guide 17 model, the updated Guide 18 is almost the same, with some added durability.
We were concerned that such a well-cushioned shoe would feel too heavy or squishy, but that wasn’t the case. Its midsole feels plush but responsive, helping us easily and quickly transition to our next stride. Plus, its cushioning performed well and held up during our back-to-back running days—a testament to its durability and quality materials.
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon, Saucony, and Zappos.
Potential Flaws
- Some wearers have noted that this shoe feels narrower than earlier models. However, it does come in wide and extra-wide sizes if your feet are wide or tend to swell when running.Â
Meet Our Testers
Our testers are regular runners who run on paved roads and gravel paths and need extra arch support. They love how supportive and energetic this shoe feels and note that its cushioning keeps their feet and legs pain-free.
-
Only comes in one width
-
Toe box may feel narrow
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 5–11, Men’s 7–14 | Weight: Women’s 7.9 ounces, Men’s 9.2 ounces | Drop: Women’s 9 millimeters, Men’s 8 millimeters | Cushioning: Plush | Materials: Recycled polyester upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.9/5
Who They’re For
Best for beginner runners who want a lightweight yet well-cushioned shoe for running on pavement or concrete.
Why We Love Them
On’s Cloudsurfer Running Shoe features soft but not too spongy cushioning, providing a supportive, responsive feel and solid shock absorption. As avid runners who run nearly every day, we were pleasantly surprised by its lightweight design, given its thick cushioning. We also noticed no pain, foot cramping, or tightness in our calves after runs, which we’ve experienced with other shoes. And we never experienced any chafing or irritation during testing. We tested the original Cloudsurfer Running Shoe, but the Cloudsurfer 2, the newest version of this shoe, has a slightly lower heel-to-toe drop and may feel firmer.
This shoe’s neutral arch support and plush midsole helped with smooth strides and dependable impact protection, especially when we ran on asphalt or concrete. We wore this pair for some longer runs, and our feet, legs, and joints felt well-supported and stable the entire time. Plus, its fit is snug and secure, and the soft, cushioned tongue and collar add to its exceptional comfort.Â
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon.
Potential Flaws
- We’d love to see this shoe in more than one width to fit runners with wide feet.
- We noticed its toe box is a little narrower than other shoes we’ve tested, which might be an issue if you have bunions, blisters, or other foot issues.
Meet Our Testers
One of our testers runs three to four times weekly and sometimes feels knee soreness or tight calf muscles during or after running. However, she found this pair had enough support and shock absorption to keep her pain-free. Our other tester runs regularly on roads or a track and sometimes feels soreness in her knees or hips after running. She usually experiences shin pain when she changes shoes, but she didn’t experience any issues while wearing these.
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 5–12 (medium, wide), Men’s 7–15 (medium, wide) | Weight: Women’s 8.2 ounces, Men’s 8.6 ounces | Drop: 10 millimeters | Cushioning: Firm and responsive | Materials: Recycled nylon upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.8/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners with flat feet or flexible arches (when the foot is flat when standing on it) who want a supportive, lightweight shoe.
Why We Love Them
If you have flat feet and a history of shin splints, you’ll appreciate the exceptional cushioning and support in Brooks’ Launch GTS 10. During test runs on pavement, concrete, and a treadmill, we were impressed by how stable and supportive they felt despite their lightweight design. Plus, their support system helps align the foot to promote a natural walking and running gait–a great feature for anyone who tends to overpronate (when the ankle rolls too far downward and inward).
This shoe’s cushioning feels springy, propelling us to the next step and effectively absorbing shock to protect our joints. We also found it helped keep leg and joint pain at bay during and after runs. With its exceptional comfort and support, we think its quality exceeds its budget-friendly price.Â
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods, and Brooks.Â
Potential Flaws
- While this shoe feels lightweight, its thick sole is on the bulkier side, which may take some getting used to.Â
Meet Our Testers
One of our testers does about four weekly runs, either on pavement or a treadmill. Our other tester runs on concrete sidewalks a couple of times a week. Both appreciated this shoe’s supportive cushioning and found it minimized their joint pain.Â
Key Specs
Sizes: Men’s 7–15, Women’s 5.5–12 | Weight: Men’s 9.8 ounces, Women’s 8.6 ounces | Drop: 0 millimeters | Cushioning: Maximum | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.7/5
Who They’re For
Best for neutral runners who want a light, nimble trail running shoe that’s well-cushioned for short or long trail runs or hikes.
Why We Love Them
Trail running, especially when going up and down hills, can be tough on your shins, so it’s crucial to have a durable shoe like Altra’s Timp 5 Trail Running Shoe for good protection. When we wore these while running on rocky, rugged New England terrain, the cushioning was very responsive and could easily withstand long distances. They felt lightweight, especially for a trail runner, and delivered good energy return, propelling us to our next stride. We never felt like we were slogging through a run and didn’t notice any leg or knee pain.
This APMA-approved shoe features a well-shaped design, comfortably accommodating our feet and ensuring a secure fit without excessive roominess or sliding. We were also impressed with its solid traction and reliable protection, thanks to its exceptionally grippy outsole that extends up the front of this shoe. They were a dream to wear on uneven terrain, keeping us confident that we wouldn’t roll an ankle or buckle a knee.
Also available in women’s sizes at Amazon, Zappos, Altra, and REI.
Potential Flaws
- This shoe runs small, so you may want to size up, especially if you’re in between sizes.
- If you’re used to running in a higher heel-to-toe drop, this shoe’s zero drop may take some time to get used to.
Meet Our Testers
Our testers are trail runners who like that this shoe feels lightweight and flexible, while still providing good protection and traction on rugged terrain. They both noted that it would also work well for hiking.
Key Specs
Sizes: Men’s 7–16 (medium, wide, extra-wide), Women’s 5–13 (narrow, medium, wide, extra-wide) | Weight: Men’s 10.5 ounces, Women’s 8.3 ounces | Drop: 6 millimeters | Cushioning: Moderate | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.8/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners with neutral arches who want a versatile shoe that works well on various surfaces and in wet conditions.
Why We Love Them
If you’re looking for a high-quality, well-cushioned, and durable shoe for wide feet, look no further than New Balance’s Fresh Foam 1080 Running Shoe. Like many of New Balance’s other models, it comes in four widths for a precise fit. During testing, the soft upper and wide toebox provided plenty of room and comfort for our forefoot, which is crucial for those who have experienced shin splints. While we tested New Balance’s Fresh Foam 1080v13, the 1080v14, the newer version of the shoe, has a slightly firmer feel.
We love that it offers the perfect balance of soft comfort, responsiveness, and shock absorption for even more protection from shin splints. Its plush padding around the collar, heel, and tongue boosted its ankle support. Plus, its rubber outsole delivers good traction and stability when we run in wet conditions and on different surfaces, including pavement, concrete, track, and a treadmill.
Also available in women’s sizes at Amazon, Zappos, and New Balance.
Potential Flaws
- During testing, we noticed some wear and tear on its outsole, so you may need to replace these shoes more often than others, depending how often you wear them.
Meet Our Testers
Our tester runs regularly and has a bunion on his foot. However, this shoe’s wide toe box offered plenty of room to accommodate the bunion, so he didn’t experience any pain or irritation.
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 4–12 (medium, wide, extra-wide), Men’s 7–16 (medium, wide, extra-wide) | Weight: Women’s 8.8 ounces, Men’s 9.8 ounces | Drop: 8 millimeters | Cushioning: Maximum | Materials: Mesh upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.9/5
Who They’re For
Best for neutral runners who want a lightweight shoe that’s plush and supportive.
Why We Love Them
If you want a running shoe with maximum cushioning, you can’t go wrong with Hoka’s Clifton Running Shoe. Its superior plush foam midsole provides excellent shock absorption and helps decrease the pressure under the heel and ball of the foot, making it a great running shoe for those prone to shin splints. We tested Hoka’s Clifton 9, but the Clifton 10, the newest model of this shoe, adds even more cushioning. However, it also loses some of the responsiveness of the Clifton 9.
They’re fairly lightweight and didn’t weigh us down, even during double-digit mileage runs or long walks. We love the extra-padded design and soft, breathable mesh upper, which gently hugs the foot, offering a secure fit. Even better, it has also received the APMA Seal of Acceptance.
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon, Dick’s Sporting Goods, Zappos, and Hoka.
Potential Flaws
- Although lightweight, this pair has thick cushioning and a wide base, so it may not be the best choice for speedwork.
Meet Our Testers
Our tester runs five to six days a week and has a history of plantar fasciitis and shin splints. She likes this shoe’s supportive cushioning, which helps her avoid leg and foot pain during long runs.
-
Excellent arch support
-
APMA Seal of Acceptance
-
Reliable traction
Key Specs
Sizes: Women’s 6–10, Men’s 7–13.5 | Weight: Women’s 11.3 ounces, Men’s 12.2 ounces | Drop: 8 millimeters | Cushioning: Moderate | Materials: Knit upper, foam midsole, rubber outsole | Our Overall Rating: 4.8/5
Who They’re For
Best for runners prone to knee pain who want to invest in a high-quality, well-cushioned, and supportive shoe.
Why We Love Them
MBT’s MTR-1500 II Running Shoe features a supportive, well-cushioned midsole that effectively absorbs shock, making it a good option if you’re prone to knee pain. During testing, its solid arch support and thick cushioning helped minimize our shin splints while alleviating knee stress and pain.Â
We like that its curved sole promotes a more natural, efficient stride, which also helps to relieve pressure on our joints. As runners who run up to 35 miles a week, we love that it provides excellent stability and great traction, thanks to its durable rubber outsole, which keeps us from sliding without feeling too sticky. Plus, these shoes have earned the APMA Seal of Acceptance.
Also available in men’s sizes at Amazon and MBT. Â
Potential Flaws
- These shoes are very supportive and well-cushioned, so they may feel bulky and heavy if you’re used to lighter shoes.
- Although they’re pricier than some other pairs on our list, we think their impact protection and support are worth investing in if you’re prone to shin splints and knee pain.
Meet Our Testers
One of our testers is just getting back into running after an injury and runs once or twice weekly. She’s prone to shin splints and plantar fasciitis, but was pleased that this pair didn’t aggravate those conditions. Our other tester runs between 25 and 35 miles a week and has nagging knee pain that often goes away after warming up.
What We’ve Updated
- Since publishing our initial part-research-based, part-tested roundup of the best running shoes for shin splints, we’ve re-evaluated our previous picks and hands-on tested the newest iterations of some of the shoes, plus eight additional pairs. This is now a fully tested article, solely providing our hands-on experience with each recommended shoe.
- We consulted two new experts, a podiatrist and an orthopedic surgeon, to ensure that our advice on choosing running shoes for shin splints is accurate and up to date.
- Based on our testing insights, we’ve reworked most of our product picks and superlatives, including Best Overall, Best Cushioned, Best for Road Running, and more.Â
What to Look for When Shopping for Running Shoes for Shin Splints
- Cushioning and Shock Absorption: One way to combat shin splints is to wear comfortable running shoes with plenty of cushioning to help absorb most of the shock from your feet hitting the ground. Opt for a shoe that has supportive cushioning and is not too soft or squishy. You’ll also want to consider your running gait. Heel strikers should have extra cushion in the heel, while those who strike midfoot will want a more evenly cushioned shoe, according to orthopedic surgeon Arianna Gianakos, DO.
- Lightweight Shoes: Look for lightweight running shoes, generally in the 10-ounce range, according to podiatrist Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, FACFAS. He notes that running long distances in heavier shoes may actually contribute to the development of shin splints.
- Heel-to-Toe Drop: A shoe’s drop refers to the difference between the height of the shoe at the heel and the forefoot. It can affect your foot strike and what part of your body takes on the load or impact of each step. A lower heel-to-toe drop is often better for runners with a midfoot or forefoot strike and puts less pressure on your knees and hips, while a higher drop (8 millimeters or more) is more suitable for rearfoot strikers who need a thicker heel. A gait analysis at a specialty running store or with a physical therapist can help determine your foot strike and the best shoes for your needs.
- Durability: Quality and durability are major factors to consider because you want to ensure the shoe’s support and cushioning won’t wear out quickly. Look for shoes with sturdy rubber outsoles that can withstand lots of pounding.
Expert Tips for Preventing and Alleviating Shin SplintsÂ
Running with shin splints could make your condition much worse, so it’s best to take some time off from running to treat them. Here are some other steps you can take to help alleviate the pain and prevent a future flare-up.
- Get the Right Support: Make sure you wear supportive, well-cushioned running shoes that are appropriate for your foot type and gait. Don’t run in worn-out shoes, and replace your running shoes regularly (usually every 300 to 400 miles).
- Do Calf and Shin Exercises and Stretches: As with all running injuries, one specific exercise or stretch won’t cure shin splints. However, people with shin splints can benefit from calf strengthening moves, including standing calf raises, toe taps, and stretches that target the shins, says podiatrist Rick Rutkowski, DPT.
- Consult an Expert: If you’ve had shin splints for more than a few weeks, it’s a good idea to see your physical therapist or doctor to rule out a stress fracture or other injury, says Rutkowski.Â
How We Tested Running Shoes for Shin Splints
To find the best running shoes for shin splints, we tested over 100 pairs in our Lab and at home while running on treadmills, pavement, gravel, trails, and more. When testing running shoes for shin splints, we evaluate each pair based on the following key criteria.
- Fit: When trying on each pair of shoes, we make sure there’s enough space in the toe box. Do we notice any numbness or tingling in our toes? We also check for a secure, supportive fit around our midfoot and heel. Do we feel our feet sliding around or moving up and down in the shoe during runs? We use these assessments to determine whether the shoe runs wide, narrow, or true to size.
- Cushioning: During testing, we note how each shoe’s cushioning feels and performs. How well does the cushioning absorb impact? Does it feel pillow-like or firm? We note whether our feet, legs, and joints hurt more or less than they normally do during runs.
- Comfort: When evaluating comfort, we consider whether the shoes feel comfortable during test runs and when wearing them for long periods of time. Is the upper breathable, or do our feet feel trapped and overheated? We also note if we notice any numbness, irritation, blisters, or other discomfort.
- Responsiveness: During test runs, we assess whether the shoe feels springy and is effective at propelling us to the next stride. We also note how our legs feel at the end of runs—do they feel fresh or fatigued? At the end of the testing period, we check the cushioning to see if it still feels bouncy or has flattened out.
- Stability: We run on different surfaces, such as pavement, concrete, treadmills, and trails, and note how supported our feet, ankles, and knees feel. Does the shoe help stabilize our gait? Does the shoe provide adequate shock absorption?
- Value: To determine value, we wait until we’ve completed testing to check the price after we’ve assessed the pair in all other key categories. Do we think it’s priced fairly based on the shoe’s performance? Would we only buy it at a discounted price? We also consider if we’d recommend the sneaker to a friend or family member.
Our Experts
We consulted experts at each stage of our research, testing, and reporting process. The following experts advised us on which key feature runners with shin splints should look for in a quality pair of running shoes and the brands they recommend. Although we choose products independently, expert input helps inform our decisions.Â
- Kevin D. Walter, MD, program director of pediatric and adolescent sports medicine at Children’s Wisconsin
- Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, FACFAS, podiatrist in New York, New York
- Rick Rutkowski, DPT, podiatrist and clinical director at Professional PT in Westfield, New Jersey
- Kristy Golden, DPM, board-certified podiatric surgeon at Kaiser Permanente in Largo, Maryland
- Arianna Gianakos, DO, Yale Medicine orthopedic surgeon at Yale Medicine in New Haven, Connecticut
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the right running shoes prevent shin splints?
Shin splints may be caused by tight calves, overpronation of the foot and ankle, and poor training habits, says Rutkowski. Wearing the right running shoes for your foot type and gait and replacing your running shoes regularly are definitely steps you can take to help prevent future occurrences of shin splints. Conversely, wearing the wrong running shoes can exacerbate foot and ankle issues.
Is it okay to run with shin splints?
While you may think it’s safe to run with mild shin splints, it’s not a good idea to run through the pain, as it could make the condition much worse. Rutkowski says it’s best to see your physical therapist or doctor if you’ve had shin splints for more than a few weeks to make sure it’s not a stress fracture.
What exercise is best for shin splints?
There isn’t one specific exercise that will alleviate or prevent shin splints. People with shin splints can benefit from various calf stretches and strengthening moves, including standing calf raises. Rutkowski recommends practicing one-legged balancing drills.Â
What type of running shoe is best for shin splints?
The best type of running shoe for shin splints is cushioned for shock absorption and has features based on your foot type and gait. For example, someone with low arches and overpronation benefits from a shoe with good arch support and stability to prevent the foot from rolling inward. Brands like Brooks, New Balance, On, and Hoka tend to offer options with adequate cushioning and support for this condition. We recommend Asics’ Novablast 4 for its superior cushioning and support.
How do you fix shin splints when running?
To ease the discomfort and reduce swelling, apply ice to your shins three times a day, do gentle stretches for your shins and calves, and take OTC pain relievers like ibuprofen or naproxen as needed. It’s also important to slow down and ease off your running routine for at least a week to give your body some recovery time. You can switch to walking or low-impact activities like biking or swimming until the shin splints resolve.
Why Trust Verywell Fit
Through many years as a running coach and marathon runner, Verywell Fit writer Christine Luff, ACE-CPT, has dealt with bouts of shin splints and advises trainees on how to prevent and recover from them. She recommends regularly replacing running shoes and sticking to reputable brands such as Asics, Brooks, New Balance, Hoka, and Saucony for shin splint protection. Aside from her own personal experience, Luff also reviewed testing insights from our lab to help choose the top picks on this list.