As adoption of ICHRA (now CHOICE Arrangement) surges, so do questions about compliance and same-terms requirements.
We get a lot of questions about ICHRA age regulations, and that is the focus of this blog. (If you’re looking for overall ICHRA compliance, take a look at ICHRA compliance FAQs and our ICHRA Guide.)
In this article:
Why are ICHRA contribution rules in place?
These ICHRA contribution rules are intended to deter employers from favoring specific individuals (discrimination) or offloading unhealthier, older, or costlier dependents onto the individual market (risk-shifting).
CHOICE Arrangement compliance exists to ensure fair, objective, and non-discriminatory practices.
What are the risks of non-compliance?
ICHRA rules are enforced by three joint regulatory bodies: the Internal Revenue Service, Department of Labor, and Department of Health and Human Services.
Non-compliant ICHRA plans can trigger significant consequences, including:
-
Employer tax penalties: Excise penalties can reach up to $100/day per affected individual
-
Employee tax impact: IRS reclassifies employee allowances from non-taxable to taxable
-
Employer mandate exposure: Voids ACA affordability safe harbors for large employers, triggering mandate penalties
- ERISA and DOL liability: Exposes the plan to compliance audits and the ICRHA can lose its legal status as a qualified group health plan
ICHRA compliance terminology
There are a lot of CHOICE Arrangement compliance terms. Some are technical and benefit from definition, and others are used informally in a way that doesn’t necessarily match regulatory intent. Here’s a brief rundown.
Same-terms requirement
ICHRA “same-terms” means that an employer must offer identical terms and conditions to every employee within a specific, IRS-approved employee class (for example part-time, salaried, or seasonal employees).
Federal regulations permit two same-terms exceptions:
-
Employee age: Employers may increase allowances based on the policy holder’s age, within a 3:1 ratio (see below for 3:1 details)
- Family size: Employers may adjust allowances based on the number of covered dependents
ICHRA 3:1 age rating rule
The 3:1 rule sets legal guardrails on age-based variation within a class. It does not require employers to use a specific curve or age multiplier; it caps the gap between the oldest and youngest employee allowances.
A clarification of “ICHRA age eligibility/rating/class”
Terms such as “ICHRA age eligibility,” “age rating,” and “age class” can refer to different employer questions. The table below clarifies what each term means in context and how ICHRA rules apply.
| Informal term | What an employer typically means when they use the term | The regulatory explanation |
| ICHRA age eligibility | “Are there age limits or age requirements to qualify for an ICHRA?” | No. Any W-2 employee in an offered class is eligible for an ICHRA, regardless of age. |
| ICHRA age rating | “Can an employer adjust ICHRA allowances based on an employee’s age?” | Only in permitted scenarios. Employers can vary ICHRA allowances by age only when the maximum contribution offered to the oldest employee in a class does not exceed 3 times the allowance offered to the youngest employee in that class. (See 3:1 ratio explainer below.) |
| ICHRA age class | “Can I create a standalone employee class based on age, like a class just for employees over 50?” | No. Federal law does not recognize age as an independent employee class. Age can only be applied within an existing, legally defined class (such as full-time or salaried workers). |
How does ICHRA contribution modeling differ from group health plans?
Group health plans
-
Pricing: The insurance company sets fixed rates for coverage tiers, such as employee only or family.
-
Employer contributions: Employers contribute the same amount for everyone in the same tier, and the tier price is not affected by the age of covered dependents.
Individual market plans (i.e. plans from ACA or a state health insurance marketplace)
-
Pricing: Insurance companies price plans based on the age and location of the employee and each individual dependent.
-
Policy amount: The total bill for the policy is the per-person costs added together. Because plan pricing takes age into account, older members will pay a higher premium than younger members on the exact same plan.
ICHRA age-related rules
-
ICHRA age regulation: Even though individual plan prices are based on every individual’s age, the employer allowance cannot be adjusted based on age.
-
Age rating allowance: Employers can increase allowances based on the employee’s age (up to a 3:1 ratio) and family size (number of covered dependents).
- Non-compliant allowances: Employers cannot increase or scale an allowance based on the age of an employee or their dependents.
Pop quiz: Which of these is compliant?
There are two 40-year-old colleagues in the same job tier. One has a 30-year-old spouse and the other has a 50-year-old spouse. They both add their spouse for ICHRA dependent coverage.
Which of these is compliant?
Employer contribution scenario #1: Both employees get the same allowance amount.
Employer contribution scenario #2: The employee with the 50-year-old spouse gets a higher allowance to compensate for the increased healthcare costs of their spouse.
It might seem logical for the employer to offer a bigger allowance to offset the (typically) higher costs of a 50 year old vs a 30 year old, but doing so violates ICHRA contribution rules.
Because same-terms rules prohibit varying contributions based on a dependent’s age, both 40-year-old employees must receive the same baseline allowance.
Answer:
Employer contribution scenario #1 is compliant.
Employer contribution scenario #2 is not compliant.
Why insurance quotes often ignore ICHRA dependent rules
Health insurance quoting software doesn’t always consider ICHRA age-rating regulations. Oftentimes, the software calculates price by adding up the cost of every person on the plan based on their age.
While this seems like a helpful way to calculate costs, reimbursement rules for ICHRA dependents are different from insurance carrier pricing. Scaling an allowance based on a dependent’s age violates same-terms rules.
Why do some ICHRA platforms miss this rule?
Many ICHRA platforms were designed around individual marketplace quoting engines. These tools calculate plan cost rather than legally compliant allowances.
We don’t see it as malicious intent, but it is a significant risk for employers. When selecting a CHOICE Arrangement administrator, we recommend that employers and brokers ask how dependent estimates are calculated.
How Take Command simplifies ICHRA compliance
Strong compliance methodology
We built the Take Command contribution model specifically for ICHRA. Our methodology adheres to individual market requirements as well as ICHRA same-terms and dependent coverage compliance.
Our model applies age-based adjustments based only on the primary employee’s age (applying the 3:1 rule as needed). When an employer chooses to fund dependent coverage, Take Command applies consistent family-tier adjustments based on the number of covered dependents, never their individual ages.
The way we calculate ICHRA contribution limits and dependent coverage ensures that employers are compliant with ICHRA requirements and federal regulations.
Expertise beyond the calculations
Not only does Take Command have a sound calculation for ICHRA compliance, we also have deep expertise. We get it that this is complicated, and we have seasoned experts on staff to help guide our clients through compliance questions.
That holds true for ICHRA contributions and dependent coverage as well as a deep bench of experts for ICHRA questions generally.
What should I ask my ICHRA administrator about contribution modeling?
Employers are the ones at risk if their allowance model is not compliant. Before partnering with an ICHRA administrator, ask these questions:
1. How does your platform calculate dependent allowances?
-
Green flag: Our platform applies dependent funding as a uniform dollar amount based on coverage tiers (such as employee + spouse) or the number of covered dependents.
-
Red flag: Our software automatically scales the allowance based on dependent age.
2. Does your quoting software enforce the 3:1 age-rating cap automatically?
-
Green flag: Yes. Our system automatically caps the allowance gap between your oldest and youngest employees within the same class so you never exceed the 3:1 legal maximum.
-
Red flag: You can choose your preferred contribution amount for each age bracket.
3. How do you ensure age-based adjustments apply only to the primary employee?
-
Green flag: Our calculation uses only the primary employee’s age for scaling and ignores dependent ages when determining adjustments.
-
Red flag: We calculate age multipliers using average household age or individual dependent ages.
4. Are your contribution models reviewed against IRS, DOL, and HHS joint regulations?
Is your ICHRA strategy compliant?
ICHRA regulations are complex, but they don’t have to be overwhelming. Take Command is here to simplify the process as much as possible, so you can enjoy all the benefits of ICHRA and ensure compliance.
Partnering with Take Command means the difference between getting an experienced administrator vs relying on an automated equation. We know this business, and when it comes to compliance, you don’t want to chance it.
Connect with an ICHRA/CHOICE Arrangement expert to build a compliant plan for your business.
Keep reading
ACA employer mandates for ALEs
Learn what applicable large employers are required to offer, the current penalty structure, compliance and reporting obligations, and how ICHRA fits into ACA compliance.
ACA employer mandates for ALEs
ICHRA employee classes
ICHRA allows employers to divide their workforce into 11 distinct classes and offer different reimbursement amounts to each.
The complete guide to HRA compliance
Adhering to ICHRA compliance keeps reimbursements tax-free for your employees, keeps your contributions deductible, and gives everyone confidence that the plan is built on solid ground.
The complete guide to HRA compliance
ICHRA compliance regulations and legal references
-
Joint Final ICHRA Regulations: Issued jointly by the Department of the Treasury, Department of Labor, and Department of Health and Human Services (84 Fed. Reg. 28888, June 20, 2019).
-
ICHRA Same-Terms Requirements & Allowed Variations: 26 CFR § 54.9802-4(c)(3).
-
ICHRA Age-Variation 3:1 Limitation Rules: 26 CFR § 54.9802-4(c)(3)(iii)(A)–(B).
-
Individual Market ACA Premium Rating Rules: 45 CFR § 147.102.
-
Excise Taxes for Non-Compliant Group Health Plans: Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 4980D (26 U.S.C. § 4980D).
-
Self-Insured Medical Reimbursement Plans & Nondiscrimination: Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 105(h).
- Employer Shared Responsibility Provisions (ACA Mandate): Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 4980H.
